Supreme Court case law

The invasion and access to case materials: assessing delays in spring 2022

Unofficial English translation of the Supreme Court’s official review

Supreme Court: The invasion and access to case materials: assessing delays in spring 2022. Case No. 373/594/22, 12.04.2023

At a glance · Bureau introduction

In case No. 373/594/22, the Criminal Cassation Court examined how hostilities and the occupation of parts of the Kyiv region affected access to case materials. Its conclusion rests on the specific reasons for the delay after notification that the investigation was complete.

Below is a complete unofficial English translation of the relevant excerpts from the Supreme Court’s thematic review published in 2026. The Ukrainian original prevails. CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine; CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine. The conclusions concern the versions of procedural law applied in the respective cases.

Supreme Court conclusion

As the lower courts noted, the suspects and defence counsel were notified on 1 March 2022 that the pre-trial investigation was complete, and were notified again on 9 March 2022. However, neither the first-instance nor the appellate court properly assessed the fact that completion of the investigation had been announced to the defence on 1 March 2022. They gave no assessment to the prosecutor's assertions that, because of the occupation of part of the Kyiv region (including Bucha), its subsequent liberation, stabilisation measures, the need to document numerous war crimes committed by the occupying forces, and demining, the pre-trial investigation authority had no objective possibility of providing the materials promptly for examination by the defence.

The courts also overlooked the prosecutor's arguments that the pre-trial investigation in these proceedings had already been completed and that the pre-trial investigation authority therefore had no need to suspend it.

The Supreme Court does not overlook the defence's arguments that it actively attempted to obtain access to and examine the criminal case materials during March–May 2022. However, the Russian Federation's full-scale invasion of Ukraine and the related events in the northern Kyiv region in the first half of 2022 provide grounds to conclude that the delay in providing the materials for the defence's examination was not attributable to unlawful inaction by the prosecution but was explained by objective and valid reasons.

Panel of Judges of the Third Judicial Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court, decision of 12.04.2023, case No. 373/594/22, proceedings No. 51-1050км23. Decision in the Unified State Register (Ukrainian).

Supreme Court review on calculating the pre-trial investigation period (current case law), 2026. p. 28.

The title and introduction were prepared by the Bureau. The review contains the principal conclusions; consult the full Ukrainian decision for the facts and complete reasoning.

Український оригінал · Ukrainian original

All publications