Supreme Court case law

Extortion: investigators’ authority, digital evidence and examination of alleged accomplices

Unofficial English translation of the Supreme Court’s official review

Вимагання: повноваження слідчих, електронні докази та допит співучасників — 285/3755/20, 17.02.2026

About this publication · Bureau introduction

The Bureau presents the decision of 17.02.2026 in case No. 285/3755/20: extortion: investigators’ authority, digital evidence and examination of alleged accomplices.

Below is a complete unofficial English translation of all corresponding passages of the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for February 2026. The review covers decisions entered in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions during that month. The title and introduction were prepared by the Bureau. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.

Complete corresponding review passage

Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted him under Article 189 § 2 CC.

In the cassation appeal, defence counsel argues that the records of inspection of a telephone, optical disc, laptop, electronic devices and flash cards are inadmissible because the person who conducted the inspections did not sign every page, and the operational officer carried them out without an assignment and is not a specialist within the meaning of Article 237 § 7 CPC.

Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate court’s ruling was quashed and a new appellate hearing was ordered.

Reasons for the Criminal Cassation Court’s position: the panel noted that, contrary to counsel’s arguments, the case file contains an assignment authorising National Police officers from an operational unit to conduct the investigative action of inspection.

In the cassation appeal, counsel alleged that the inspection records for the telephone, optical disc, laptop, electronic devices and flash cards were inadmissible because not every page bore the signature of the person conducting that investigative action.

However, the panel draws attention to the fact that the CPC, in particular Article 104, does not require the person conducting an investigative action to sign every sheet of its record.

Complete corresponding review passage

Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted him under Article 189 § 2 CC.

In the cassation appeal, defence counsel submits that investigators of the Main Directorate of the National Police acted outside their powers because no assignment to conduct the pre-trial investigation under Article 36 § 5 CPC had been issued.

Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate court’s ruling was quashed and a new appellate hearing was ordered.

Reasons for the Criminal Cassation Court’s position: the panel noted that the pre-trial investigation materials concerning the accused had been severed from those of the original criminal proceedings.

The defence drew attention to the absence of an assignment to conduct the pre-trial investigation in the severed case.

The panel stated that the CPC does not require repeated appointment of an investigator in proceedings severed from or joined to another case if an investigator or investigative team was already appointed after the investigation began. Nor do the rules of Article 217 CPC require this.

Accordingly, investigators authorised to conduct the original pre-trial investigation did not automatically lose their powers in the severed proceedings. The investigative or prosecutorial team may of course be changed, but that requires an appropriate formal decision.

In light of this cassation case law, the appellate court correctly concluded that the investigator and prosecutor were authorised to conduct the pre-trial investigation.

Complete corresponding review passage

Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted him under Article 189 § 2 CC.

In the cassation appeal, defence counsel submitted that the records of inspection of a telephone, optical disc, laptop, electronic devices and flash cards were inadmissible because the operational officer conducted them without an assignment and was not a specialist within the meaning of Article 237 § 7 CPC.

Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate ruling was quashed and a new appellate hearing was ordered.

Reasons for the Criminal Cassation Court’s position: the panel rejected this argument because photographing and saving images from the messaging applications in which the victim communicated about transferring money did not require specialist knowledge. The victim supplied the telephone to the operational officer precisely to record and preserve that correspondence.

Accordingly, the panel sees no grounds for treating the inspection records drawn up by the operational officer, acting as an authorised person, as inadmissible evidence.

Complete corresponding review passage

Facts of the case: the accused, together with others, extorted money from the victim through threats and violence. Person 1 and Person 2 forced the victim into a car and demanded money while striking his head and upper limbs. At a prearranged deserted location, the accused again demanded UAH 100,000 and set specific payment dates. The victim then, accompanied by Persons 1, 2 and 3 and other unidentified people, took UAH 3,000 from a shop and handed it to Person 2. Subsequently, the accused, among others, sent messages through a social network demanding the remaining money. During a meeting with Persons 1, 2 and 3, the accused confirmed by telephone to the victim that the money had to be handed over, after which the victim gave UAH 20,000 to Persons 1, 2 and 3.

Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted him under Article 189 § 2 CC.

In the cassation appeal, defence counsel alleges a violation of the right to defence because the substance of the accusation was not explained and no information was provided about the people with whom the accused allegedly committed the offence.

Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate court’s ruling was quashed and a new appellate hearing was ordered.

Reasons for the Criminal Cassation Court’s position: the panel noted that the indictment mentions Person 1, Person 2 and Person 3, and charges the accused with committing the offence under Article 189 § 2 CC together with them.

In its judgment, the trial court rejected counsel’s argument that the indictment failed to comply with Article 291 CPC because it did not identify Persons 1, 2 and 3 and neither counsel nor the accused was told their surnames, first names and patronymics during the proceedings. It reasoned that this was precisely how an indictment should refer to people who had not been convicted.

In reviewing the trial judgment, the appellate court stated that Persons 1, 2 and 3 were not parties to these criminal proceedings within the meaning of Article 3 CPC. It failed to give due attention to the defence’s argument that the qualifying element under Article 189 § 2 CC charged against the accused had to be established.

The appellate court did not assess counsel’s argument that these people had not been questioned.

The panel disagrees that people whose criminal cases are being heard separately and who are not evading the court cannot be questioned in proceedings where another person is charged with committing the offence jointly with them.

In addition, the court must examine and take into account the judicial decisions concerning the other people with whom the accused allegedly committed the act.

Accordingly, at the new appellate hearing, the appellate court must re-examine the circumstances concerning extortion committed by a group of persons.

Decision details and sources

The review contains the principal conclusions. Consult the full judicial decision in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions for a complete understanding of the legal position. The decision link and details are reproduced from the official review.

Related publications

Читати українською

All publications