Author publication · Conference paper

Criminal proceedings in war-crime cases: balancing the presumption of innocence and the public demand for justice

Обкладинка авторської публікації Олександра Тіньковського про презумпцію невинуватості у справах про воєнні злочини

English summary

This page provides an English summary of a Ukrainian conference paper by Oleksandr Tinkovskyi, a postgraduate researcher at Donetsk State University of Internal Affairs. The complete Ukrainian text, including its bibliography, is available through the link below.

The paper examines the presumption of innocence in investigations of war crimes and the duty to seek evidence that may exonerate a suspect. It considers how public demands for prompt accountability can coexist with a thorough and impartial investigation.

Investigations conducted in areas affected by hostilities may involve restricted access to locations, witnesses and physical evidence. The author emphasises the need to verify the authenticity of material and documentary evidence and to assess information favourable to the suspect with the same care as incriminating information.

Particular attention is given to proceedings in absentia. When an accused person is unavailable and counsel cannot obtain a complete account from the client, the practical imbalance between prosecution and defence may increase. The paper argues that investigators and prosecutors must actively identify and record potentially exculpatory circumstances, while ensuring that proceedings remain adversarial and fair.

The author discusses Articles 7, 9, 84 and 92 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The conclusion calls for a balanced approach to collecting and disclosing evidence, effective participation by defence counsel and careful documentation of circumstances capable of exonerating a person or mitigating liability.

Figures and references in the original paper reflect the period in which it was written; they are not presented as current statistics.

Read the full article in Ukrainian
All publications