About this publication · Bureau introduction
The Bureau presents a judgment concerning seizure of a civilian’s property, deprivation of liberty and removal to an unknown destination. The material includes the assessment of the defence’s argument about acting on orders.
Below is a complete unofficial English translation of the corresponding material in the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for March 2026. The review covers decisions entered in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions during that month. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.
Full review passage
Circumstances of the case: the court found it proved that, on 7 March 2022 in the temporarily occupied village of Hremiach, Novhorod-Siverskyi District, Chernihiv Region, the convicted person, a member of the Russian armed forces acting by prior conspiracy with other servicemen, openly seized the victim’s Mitsubishi Pajero and Ford Tranzit vehicles, worth a total of UAH 486,800. Threatening the victim with automatic weapons, they placed him in one of the stolen vehicles and, escorted by military armoured vehicles, took him towards Ukraine’s border with the Russian Federation.
Positions of the first-instance and appellate courts: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted him under Article 28 § 2 and Article 438 § 1 CC.
In the cassation appeal, defence counsel argued that the prosecution had not disproved that the convicted person was acting on an order whose criminal nature was not apparent to him, so neither commission of a crime nor “prior conspiracy by a group of persons” could be established.
Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the lower courts’ decisions were left unchanged.
Reasons for the Criminal Cassation Court’s position: the panel stated that reasonable doubt must not be purely speculative. It must rest on circumstances established by the court, or on failure to prove circumstances important to the case, giving grounds to suppose a course of events inconsistent with the prosecution’s account that cannot be refuted by the evidence submitted by the parties.
In these proceedings, the circumstances established by the lower courts gave no grounds to suppose that the acts were performed pursuant to a lawful order.
The courts established that the convicted person and other Russian servicemen deprived the victim of liberty and seized his vehicles without stating any legal grounds, then took him to an unknown destination without giving his wife any information or explanation and without drawing up any documents recording those actions.
The servicemen’s conduct at the victims’ home and afterwards, particularly the fact that the victim’s fate remained unknown, gave no grounds to consider that they were executing an order connected with a lawful investigation. It instead demonstrated a classic example of enforced disappearance committed by representatives of the occupying authorities.
Even if the servicemen, including the convicted person, acted on orders from their commander or superior, those orders clearly conflicted with international humanitarian law and the domestic law of both the occupied State and the occupying State. Accordingly, under Article 41 § 4 CC, the convicted person, who acted in complicity with other Russian servicemen, bears responsibility for his acts on the ordinary basis.
Decision details and sources
- Judgment of the panel of judges of the First Judicial Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court of 17.03.2026, case No. 739/772/24 (proceedings No. 51-2759км25)
- Official Criminal Cassation Court review for March 2026 — pp. 29, 30
Unofficial English translation of the full corresponding passage of the official Supreme Court review. The title, introduction and editorial notes were prepared by the Bureau. The review contains the principal conclusions; consult the Ukrainian judicial decision for the full reasoning.

