About this publication · Bureau introduction
The Bureau presents the decision of 23.02.2026 in case No. 381/1863/18: decriminalisation after acquittal: the appellate court’s duties.
Below is a complete unofficial English translation of all corresponding passages of the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for February 2026. The review covers decisions entered in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions during that month. The title and introduction were prepared by the Bureau. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.
Complete corresponding review passage
Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the trial court found the person not guilty and acquitted her under Article 185 §§ 1 and 2 CC on the basis of Article 373 § 1 (3) CPC because the elements of a criminal offence in her conduct had not been proved. The appellate court quashed that judgment and closed the proceedings under Article 284 § 2 (1-2) CPC.
In the cassation appeal, the person in respect of whom the proceedings were closed stresses that the appellate court unjustifiably closed them following the prosecutor’s appeal without her consent. In her view, having established grounds for closure and the accused’s lack of consent, the court had to determine whether the offence occurred and whether her conduct contained its elements. Only if guilt was proved could it close the proceedings; if no elements of an offence were established, it had to acquit under Article 284 § 7 (1) CPC.
Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate court’s ruling was quashed and a new appellate hearing was ordered.
Reasons for the Criminal Cassation Court’s position: the panel noted that the trial judgment found the person not guilty of the offences under Article 185 §§ 1 and 2 CC and acquitted her because the elements of a criminal offence in her conduct had not been proved.
The prosecutor disagreed with the acquittal and appealed. The appellate court opened proceedings on that appeal.
Subsequently, following the entry into force on 09.08.2024 of Law No. 3886-IX, under which criminal liability under Articles 185, 190 and 191 CC can arise only if the value stolen exceeds two non-taxable minimum incomes, the appellate court quashed the acquittal and closed the proceedings under Article 284 § 2 (1-2) CPC.
The prosecutor appealed because he disagreed with the acquittal. However, without examining his arguments, giving thorough answers to them or taking account of the person’s lack of consent, the appellate court closed the proceedings.
Moreover, while disagreeing with the trial court and thus making its own assessment of the evidence, it neither examined that evidence nor analysed each item for relevance, reliability and admissibility, or the evidence as a whole for sufficiency.
In hearing the prosecutor’s appeal, the appellate court failed to consider Chapter 36-1 CPC, which governs proceedings concerning conduct criminalised by a law that has ceased to be in force.
In particular, under Article 479-2 § 1 CPC, such proceedings follow the general procedure laid down in the Code, subject to the special features specified in that Article.
Under paragraph 3 of that Article, if the law establishing the criminal nature of the conduct ceases to be in force during judicial proceedings in a case submitted with an indictment, the court:
1. suspends the trial;
2. seeks the accused’s consent to closure under Article 284 § 1 (4-1) of the Code;
3. if the accused does not object, closes the proceedings on that ground.
Alternatively, where the accused does not consent:
1) if the court establishes that the accused committed conduct criminalised by the law that has ceased to be in force, it issues a ruling closing the proceedings under Article 284 § 2 (1-2) of the Code;
2) if the court does not establish that the accused committed that conduct, it delivers an acquittal.
Where grounds existed, the appellate court should have examined the prosecutor’s appeal challenging the acquittal’s lawfulness, given reasoned answers to the arguments about whether the person’s conduct contained the elements of the offence charged, and adopted a decision provided for in Article 407 CPC, taking account of Articles 284 and 479-2 CPC.
Thus, by closing the proceedings in this manner, the appellate court failed to comply with Articles 370, 404, 419 and 479-2 CPC and prematurely quashed the judgment.
Decision details and sources
- Judgment of a panel of the Third Judicial Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court of 23.02.2026, case No. 381/1863/18 (proceedings No. 51-4587км25)
- Official Criminal Cassation Court review for February 2026 — pp. 59, 60, 61
The review contains the principal conclusions. Consult the full judicial decision in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions for a complete understanding of the legal position. The decision link and details are reproduced from the official review.

