Supreme Court case law

Domestic violence: restrictive measures to protect the victim

Unofficial English translation of the Supreme Court’s official review

Домашнє насильство: обмежувальні заходи для захисту потерпілої. ККС ВС, 19.02.2026, 148/2742/24.

About this publication · Bureau introduction

The Bureau presents the decision of 19.02.2026 in case No. 148/2742/24: domestic violence: restrictive measures to protect the victim.

Below is a complete unofficial English translation of all corresponding passages of the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for February 2026. The review covers decisions entered in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions during that month. The title and introduction were prepared by the Bureau. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.

Complete corresponding review passage

Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the local court found the accused guilty and convicted him under Article 309 § 1 and Article 126-1 CC. The appellate court quashed the judgment in respect of the sentence and delivered a new judgment sentencing him under Article 126-1 CC to two years’ restriction of liberty, with the obligations under Article 91-1(4) and (5) CC. Under those provisions, the following restrictive measures were applied:

– a three-month prohibition on correspondence, telephone conversations and other contact with the victim through communication devices or electronic communications, either personally or through third parties;

– referral of the accused to an intervention programme for perpetrators for three months.

In his cassation appeal, defence counsel points out that restrictive measures are addressed in a separate section of the CC and are regarded as other non-punitive, although coercive, measures of a criminal-law nature; criminal-law measures; neither a constituent element nor a separate form of criminal liability. They are not imposed independently and, by their legal nature, the restrictive measures provided for in the CC should be classified as security measures. He argues that, in the challenged judgment, the appellate court relied on Article 414 CPC as grounds for partly quashing the local court’s judgment and concluded that a restrictive measure under Article 91-1 CC, contained in Section XIII-1, Restrictive Measures, could be imposed as punishment. He therefore considers that there are grounds to amend the appellate court’s judgment.

Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate court’s judgment was upheld.

Reasoning of the Criminal Cassation Court: the panel noted that the appellate court agreed that the local court had imposed two years’ restriction of liberty under Article 126-1 CC within the prescribed sanction. However, in its reasons the appellate court identified an incorrect application of the law of Ukraine on criminal liability, namely the failure to apply a law that should have been applied in the criminal proceedings.

The panel agreed with the appellate court’s conclusions set out above for the following reasons.

Under Article 91-1 § 1 CC, in the interests of a victim of a crime related to domestic violence, the court may apply one or more restrictive measures to the person who committed domestic violence at the same time as imposing a sentence not involving deprivation of liberty, or granting exemption from criminal liability or punishment on grounds provided for in the CC. Under such measures, the following obligations may be imposed on the convicted person:

– a prohibition on staying at the place of residence shared with the person who suffered domestic violence;

– restrictions on communication with a child if domestic violence was committed against the child or in the child’s presence;

– a prohibition on approaching within a specified distance of a place where the person who suffered domestic violence may reside permanently or temporarily, or may stay temporarily or regularly for work, study, treatment or other reasons;

– a prohibition on correspondence, telephone conversations and other contact with the person who suffered domestic violence through communication devices or electronic communications, either personally or through third parties;

– referral to an intervention programme for perpetrators.

Under Article 91-1 § 3 CC, the measures provided for in paragraph 1 may be applied for one to three months and, if necessary, extended for a period determined by the court, but by no more than twelve months.

Here, the criminal-law consequences of the accused’s conduct include court-imposed restrictive measures prohibiting correspondence, telephone conversations and other contact with the victim through communication devices or electronic communications, personally or through third parties, and requiring participation in an intervention programme for perpetrators. Those consequences must therefore be determined by the CC.

It should also be noted that the provisions of the Law On Preventing and Combating Domestic Violence are fully consistent with the CC, taking into account that the procedure for applying these measures is determined by the CC and the CPC and allows their extension.

Consequently, having regard to the circumstances of the criminal offence taken into account by the appellate court—namely that the accused had committed domestic violence over a prolonged period against his mother, an elderly person over sixty years of age, causing her psychological suffering; had a mediocre character reference at his place of residence; had mental disorders confirmed by the relevant documents in the proceedings; and required treatment—the panel considered that the appellate court’s conclusions on applying the restrictive measures under Article 91-1(4) and (5) CC were based on the criminal law, were reasoned and justified, and that the measures were necessary to safeguard the victim’s rights by preventing and stopping repeated violence as well as threats of violence.

Decision details and sources

The review contains the principal conclusions. Consult the full judicial decision in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions for a complete understanding of the legal position. The decision link and details are reproduced from the official review.

Related publications

Читати українською

All publications