Supreme Court case law

Prosecutor’s cassation appeal: referral to the Grand Chamber

Unofficial English translation of the Supreme Court’s official review

Касація прокурора: передача до Великої Палати

About this publication · Bureau introduction

The Bureau presents the review’s account of a prosecutor’s authority to lodge a cassation appeal in a convicted person’s interests. The material concerns the referral ruling and the referring panel’s reasons; it does not state a final conclusion of the Grand Chamber.

Below is a complete unofficial English translation of the corresponding material in the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for March 2026. The review covers decisions entered in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions during that month. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.

Full review passage

Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted him under Part 3 of Article 185 and Part 2 of Article 389 CC.

The prosecutor challenged the appellate court’s ruling on the grounds that the convicted person’s right to defence had been violated. The cassation court left the prosecutor’s cassation appeal without movement because she had not substantiated her authority to represent the convicted person’s interests in court. Within the period allowed, the prosecutor filed a new cassation appeal and, to substantiate her entitlement to lodge it, referred to the judgment of the Judicial Chamber for Criminal Cases of the Supreme Court of Ukraine of 21 January 2016 in case No. 5-332кс15.

In that judgment, having considered the issue of the inadmissibility of a prosecutor’s cassation appeal where it was filed in the interests of a convicted person and the matters raised did not concern the prosecutor’s prosecutorial functions, the Supreme Court of Ukraine concluded that the rules in paragraph 20 of Part 2 of Article 36 and paragraph 6 of Part 1 of Article 425 CPC empower the prosecutor, as a party to criminal proceedings, to lodge a cassation appeal against the judicial decisions specified in Article 424 CPC on the grounds of a violation of the accused’s right to defence, that is, to initiate cassation proceedings with a view to obtaining a decision in favour of the convicted person.

Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the criminal proceedings were referred to the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court.

Grounds for referring the criminal proceedings to the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court: the need to depart from the conclusion in the judgment of the Supreme Court of Ukraine of 21 January 2016 in case No. 5-332кс15.

Reasoning of the Criminal Cassation Court: the panel of judges considers that the Supreme Court of Ukraine’s conclusion concerning the prosecutor’s unrestricted right to lodge a cassation appeal does not take account of either the CPC or the legislation governing prosecutors’ activities.

Restrictions on prosecutors’ activities in legal proceedings, including criminal proceedings, are imposed by the Constitution and the laws governing the prosecution service. In those circumstances, the legislature had no need to provide for the same restrictions in a procedural rule governing a particular aspect of proceedings, understanding that they were regulated by other legal provisions.

The absence of restrictions on prosecutors’ ability to challenge judicial decisions on appeal and in cassation creates conditions for abuse of that right, entails unnecessary expenditure of participants’ time, unjustified workloads for appellate and cassation courts, and additional expenditure of public funds.

The panel considers that, when examining these proceedings, the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court should depart from the Supreme Court of Ukraine’s conclusion in the judgment of 21 January 2016 in case No. 5-332кс15 and reach a different conclusion: within paragraph 6 of Part 1 of Article 425 CPC, a prosecutor is entitled to lodge a cassation appeal against judicial decisions on grounds of incorrect application of Ukrainian criminal liability law, a sentence being disproportionate to the seriousness of the criminal offence and the convicted person’s circumstances, or a substantial violation of criminal procedural law constituting an unconditional ground for setting aside a judicial decision (Part 2 of Article 412 CPC).

In other cases, when lodging a cassation appeal in the interests of a convicted person or a victim on grounds of a substantial violation of criminal procedural law which prevented or could have prevented the court from delivering a lawful and reasoned decision, the prosecutor must agree the possibility of lodging such an appeal with the convicted person or the victim.

Decision details and sources

Unofficial English translation of the full corresponding passage of the official Supreme Court review. The title, introduction and editorial notes were prepared by the Bureau. The review contains the principal conclusions; consult the Ukrainian judicial decision for the full reasoning.

Read also

All publications