Supreme Court case law

An appeal lodged with the wrong court: can the missed time limit be restored?

Unofficial English translation of the Supreme Court’s official review

Criminal Cassation Court: An appeal lodged with the wrong court: can the missed time limit be restored?. Case No. 757/39249/25-к, 12.05.2026

About this material · Bureau introduction

The Criminal Cassation Court reviewed a refusal to restore the time limit for appealing an investigating judge’s ruling. The assessment focused on the mistaken filing with the High Anti-Corruption Court’s Appeals Chamber and counsel’s subsequent delay.

Below is a complete unofficial English translation of the relevant passages from the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for May 2026. The Ukrainian original prevails. The review period refers to entry of decisions in the Register, not necessarily the date on which they were delivered. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.

Mistaken identification of the court and valid reasons for delay

The positions of the trial and appellate courts: the local court investigating judge granted the prosecutor’s application to attach property. The appellate court refused the application to restore the time limit for appealing that ruling and returned the appeal to the person who lodged it under Article 399 § 3 (4) of the CPC. The appellate court reasoned that, contrary to Article 395 § 2 (3) of the CPC, the lawyer had lodged the appeal after the five-day time limit and that it had found no grounds, on that person’s application, to restore the time limit.

In the cassation appeal, the lawyer argued that the appeal time limit had been missed because inconsistent judicial practice made it impossible to identify the proper appellate court with certainty, resulting in his appeal to the Appeals Chamber of the High Anti-Corruption Court rather than a court of appeal of general jurisdiction.

The position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate court’s ruling was left unchanged.

The reasoning of the Criminal Cassation Court: on examining the criminal case file, the panel established that the lawyer had received a copy of the local court investigating judge’s ruling on 3 August 2025 and had appealed against it to the High Anti-Corruption Court’s Appeals Chamber on 4 September 2025.

Subsequently, on 8 September 2025, a judge of that Appeals Chamber returned the appeal to the person who lodged it because the challenged decision had been made by an investigating judge of a local court of general jurisdiction. It could therefore be reviewed on appeal by the relevant court of appeal of general jurisdiction within whose territorial jurisdiction the trial court that delivered it was located.

However, according to the cassation appellant himself, it was only after a Criminal Cassation Court panel set out its position in a decision of 9 December 2025 that he understood that he had mistakenly appealed against the investigating judge’s decision to the High Anti-Corruption Court’s Appeals Chamber; he therefore appealed to a court of appeal of general jurisdiction only on 12 December 2025.

In the panel’s view, those circumstances — namely the procedural conduct of the lawyer, who delayed appealing against the investigating judge’s ruling to a court of appeal of general jurisdiction and lodged an appeal in breach of the jurisdiction prescribed, in particular, by Article 3 § 1 (20) of the CPC, together with the lengthy period since the procedural time limit expired — did not establish objective obstacles preventing him from exercising his right to appeal against the local court investigating judge’s ruling to the appropriate appellate court.

Thus, the appellate court considered the application within the arguments advanced by the lawyer and, in the absence of valid reasons for missing the appeal time limit, reasonably and with sufficient reasons refused to restore it and returned the appeal under Article 399 § 3 (4) of the CPC.

Judgment of a panel of the Second Judicial Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court of 12.05.2026 in case No. 757/39249/25-к (proceedings No. 51-4617км25). Decision in the official Register.

Official Criminal Cassation Court review for May 2026, p. 41, p. 42.

Український оригінал · Ukrainian original

All publications