Supreme Court case law

Defects in an appeal and excessive formalism

Unofficial English translation of the Supreme Court’s official review

Недоліки апеляційної скарги та надмірний формалізм — 484/5239/23, 29.01.2026

About this publication · Bureau introduction

The Bureau presents the decision of 29.01.2026 in case No. 484/5239/23: defects in an appeal and excessive formalism.

Below is a complete unofficial English translation of all corresponding passages of the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for February 2026. The review covers decisions entered in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions during that month. The title and introduction were prepared by the Bureau. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.

Complete corresponding review passage

Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the trial court found the accused guilty and convicted him under Article 115 § 1 CC. An appellate judge returned the appeal lodged by counsel acting for the accused under Article 399 § 3 (1) CPC.

In the cassation appeal, counsel stated that the appeal sought to quash the trial judgment and adopt a new decision finding the accused not guilty of the offence under Article 115 § 1 CC. In her view, this was broadly consistent with the appellate court’s powers under Article 407 § 1 (4), Article 417 and Article 418 § 1 CPC to issue a ruling closing proceedings under Article 284 § 1 (3) and Article 412 § 2 (1) CPC.

Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the appellate judge’s ruling was quashed and a new appellate hearing was ordered.

Reasons for the Criminal Cassation Court’s position: the panel noted that the appellate judge identified the following shortcomings in the appeal:

- Counsel asked for the trial judgment to be quashed and the accused to be found not guilty of the offence charged. However, these requests were unspecific and required clarification, as they did not take account of the appellate court’s powers and consequently prevented that court from determining the scope of the appeal, examining its merits and adopting a decision within its statutory powers;

- In breach of Article 396 § 6 CPC, counsel did not attach enough copies of the appeal to send to the participants in the proceedings.

The appellate court subsequently received clarifications to counsel’s appeal together with attachments, including the required number of copies.

However, when deciding whether to open appellate proceedings, the appellate judge observed that the clarified appeal, submitted in response to the earlier ruling, again requested that the trial judgment be quashed and a new decision adopted finding the accused not guilty. The judge regarded these requests as unclear and formulated without regard to the decisions the appellate court could adopt under Articles 407 and 420 CPC.

The judge therefore concluded that counsel had not remedied the shortcomings identified in the ruling leaving the appeal without further action pending correction, and that the appeal had to be returned under Article 399 § 3 (1) CPC.

In the panel’s view, these conclusions were premature.

The panel states that when deciding whether grounds exist to open appellate proceedings, the reporting judge must consider the extent to which the appellate panel’s procedural powers can be exercised in light of the relief sought, taking account of Article 2; Article 7 (1), (12), (13), (14) and (17); Article 284 §§ 1 and 2; and Articles 404, 407, 417 and 418 CPC during appellate review.

The decisive question is whether the appellate court can examine the appeal within its powers and, despite obvious shortcomings, grant it in part. If so, the court can determine the scope of the appeal and thereby secure access to justice under the CPC.

The case file shows that counsel’s appeal alleged violations by the trial court under Articles 410, 412 and 413 CPC: the accused’s guilt had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt, his testimony had not been refuted, contradictions in the evidence had not been resolved, and the trial decision relied on assumptions and inadmissible evidence.

Thus, given the appeal’s content, which the appellate judge’s ruling leaving it without further action did not question in this respect, the appellate court could, if it accepted the defence’s arguments that the judgment was unlawful, exercise its powers under the CPC despite the requested relief not conforming to Article 407. It could apply Article 404 § 2 CPC, grant the appeal in part and, under the procedural provisions cited above, if sufficient grounds were established during appellate review, quash the trial decision and issue a ruling closing the proceedings in accordance with the CPC.

The panel accordingly concludes that the appellate judge’s finding that the scope of the appeal could not be determined and its merits could not be considered because of the defence’s incorrectly worded requests was not properly reasoned. Counsel’s cassation argument that the judge resorted to excessive formalism when deciding whether to open proceedings, thereby failing to follow the European Court of Human Rights’ case law, is therefore well-founded.

Decision details and sources

The review contains the principal conclusions. Consult the full judicial decision in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions for a complete understanding of the legal position. The decision link and details are reproduced from the official review.

Related publications

Читати українською

All publications