About this publication · Bureau introduction
The Bureau presents the decision of 26.01.2026 in case No. 343/734/17: the features of an armed gang and appellate review after expulsion.
Below is a complete unofficial English translation of all corresponding passages of the Criminal Cassation Court’s official review for February 2026. The review covers decisions entered in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions during that month. The title and introduction were prepared by the Bureau. CC means the Criminal Code of Ukraine; CPC means the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.
Complete corresponding review passage
Facts of the case: the court established that in August 2015 the accused, motivated by gain and seeking regular unlawful income through attacks to take other people’s property, formed and led a stable armed group—a gang—recruiting three other accused as perpetrators who had organised in advance to attack members of the public. Acting within that armed gang between August 2015 and 6 August 2016, the accused planned, prepared and committed a theft and a series of armed attacks to take property, following a previously developed criminal plan and an agreed allocation of roles.
Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted them under Article 146 § 3, Article 185 § 5, Article 187 § 4, Article 14 § 1 in conjunction with Article 187 § 4, Article 257 and Article 262 § 3 CC.
In the cassation appeals, the defence argues that none of the qualifying characteristics of an organised group was proved and that the convicted persons’ acquaintance with one another does not establish the stability or even the existence of such a group or gang.
Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the decisions of the lower courts were upheld.
Reasoning of the Criminal Cassation Court: the panel noted that the case file showed that the gang had been formed to obtain unlawful income regularly by taking other people’s property.
The local court referred to the following:
– acting within the armed gang that had been formed and led, between August 2015 and 6 August 2016 in the Khmelnytskyi, Zhytomyr and Ivano-Frankivsk regions, the accused planned, prepared and committed a theft and a series of armed attacks under a previously developed criminal plan and an agreed allocation of roles, unlawfully obtaining the victims’ money and property worth UAH 213,460 in total;
– all the available evidence showed careful and prolonged preparation for the attacks, consistent with the definition of the offence in Article 257 CC;
– the gang’s stable membership was confirmed by lasting criminal connections and relationships among its members and their awareness of the nature and purpose of their unlawful acts. Its stability was also shown by the fact that the accused committed all the charged crimes with the same membership and that the accused repeatedly engaged the same driver for transport. The gang’s persistence was demonstrated by the attacks and by the members’ continued contact not only during the crimes, but also before and afterwards;
– the allocation of roles was confirmed by the accused’s successful performance as leader of the armed gang he had organised and his actions towards their common criminal objective: ensuring the gang’s mobility, assigning each accomplice’s role, arranging concealment through switching off mobile phones to prevent connections being identified during the crimes, regularly changing SIM cards, storing stolen property and so forth;
– the accused used and carried weapons, took measures to disguise themselves, participated in all the crimes and exerted physical and psychological pressure on the victims by displaying weapons, threatening their use and using them during the crimes. They demanded money and valuables and searched for them in the premises attacked. The victims’ testimony confirmed coordinated actions and clear performance of roles. One victim also testified that the grass near his house had been trampled and a window damaged before the attack, indicating preparation, and that a fourth attacker arrived later during the attack.
The local court therefore found that:
– all members of the armed gang knew its purpose and methods, knew that its members possessed firearms and other weapons and used them during gang attacks, and understood that weapons could be used during attacks and to overcome victims’ resistance;
– the armed gang formed and led by the accused was durable, stable, cohesive and clearly organised around a single criminal purpose and planned armed attacks, with roles allocated to each member;
– under the criminal plan and allocation of roles previously agreed by all members of the stable armed group, each subordinate member performed their assigned function with the accused’s knowledge and under his direct leadership and was ready, when necessary, to perform any acts aimed at achieving their common criminal objective.
In these circumstances, the first-instance court concluded that a stable association had been created to commit crimes.
These conclusions of the first-instance court were properly substantiated and reasoned. Accordingly, the cassation arguments alleging the absence of the characteristics of an organised criminal group were unfounded.
Complete corresponding review passage
Positions of the courts of first instance and appeal: the lower courts found the accused guilty and convicted them under Article 146 § 3, Article 185 § 5, Article 187 § 4, Article 14 § 1 in conjunction with Article 187 § 4, Article 257 and Article 262 § 3 CC.
In the cassation appeal, the defence argues that the appellate court heard the case in the accused’s absence, contrary to Article 412 § 1 and § 2(3) CPC.
Position of the Criminal Cassation Court: the decisions of the lower courts were upheld.
Reasoning of the Criminal Cassation Court: the panel considered it necessary to note the following matters shown by the case file:
– the appellate court revoked the accused’s preventive measure and released him from custody because the time spent in pre-trial detention covered the prison sentence imposed by the challenged judgment and the prosecutor had not appealed;
– after his release, the accused, a citizen of the Republic of Georgia, was forcibly expelled from Ukraine by a decision of the acting head of the State Migration Service Directorate’s unit for preventing irregular migration, readmission and expulsion;
– defence counsel applied to the appellate court for his client to participate in the hearing. In support, counsel stated, among other things, that according to the accused he could not register in the Electronic Court subsystem because he was abroad and could not obtain a qualified electronic signature, while the system recognised only signatures issued by Ukrainian state authorities and banking institutions. Counsel also stated that the accused could participate from outside the court using his own equipment through Skype or Viber.
The audio recording of the hearing also shows that, following the application, the appellate court adjourned, including to ascertain the technical feasibility of a videoconference in those circumstances.
However, in its decision following the hearing, the appellate court stated that the accused, despite being notified of its time and place, had not registered in the Electronic Court subsystem, had not personally applied to participate by videoconference from another location and had not provided the information needed to organise a videoconference in compliance with the applicable Regulation.
The appellate court also took into account that the accused’s participation in the appellate hearing was not mandatory and concluded that the appeal could proceed in his absence.
In those circumstances, given the impossibility of holding a videoconference in compliance with the Regulation, the panel also took into account that:
– the accused had been forcibly expelled from Ukraine;
– his participation in the appellate proceedings was not mandatory;
– he had not been deprived of legal assistance, because his defence counsel, whose participation was mandatory under Article 52 CPC, attended the appellate hearing;
– he had not personally applied to the appellate court under Article 401 § 4 CPC to participate in the hearing by videoconference;
– the appellate court had not deprived him of the opportunity to participate by videoconference under the CPC. Holding the appellate hearing in his absence was therefore not a substantial breach of criminal procedure law that prevented or could have prevented a lawful and reasoned appellate decision, nor did it mean that the decision was subject to unconditional reversal.
Decision details and sources
- Judgment of a panel of the First Judicial Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court of 26.01.2026, case No. 343/734/17 (proceedings No. 51-4983км19)
- Official Criminal Cassation Court review for February 2026 — pp. 22, 23, 24, 54, 55, 56
The review contains the principal conclusions. Consult the full judicial decision in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions for a complete understanding of the legal position. The decision link and details are reproduced from the official review.

